Is Your Competition's Brand Stronger Than Yours? A 5-Point Checklist

You’ve seen it before. You drive past a job site and see your competitor’s truck. You scroll through Instagram and see their ad. You hear a friend mention they used their service. Each time, there’s a small, nagging question: Why them and not me?

Often, the difference isn’t the quality of the work—it’s the strength of the brand. A strong brand builds trust, creates recognition, and makes the choice easy for customers. A weak brand, even for a great business, creates doubt and gets overlooked.

So, where do you stand? It’s time to stop guessing and start measuring. This simple brand audit is designed to give you an honest, objective look at how your brand stacks up against your number one competitor.

---

How to Use This Checklist

Grab a pen and paper. Pick your top local competitor—the one you see everywhere. For each of the five points below, read the description and honestly score both yourself and your competitor on a scale of 1 (Weak) to 5 (Excellent).

The 5-Point Brand-vs-Brand Audit

Compare your brand against a competitor on key metrics.

1

The First Impression: Visual Consistency

A brand’s visuals are its uniform. When it's consistent, it looks professional and trustworthy. Look at everything from the logo, colors, and fonts to the style of photography.

Audit Questions:

• Is their logo used the same way everywhere?
• Are their brand colors consistent across all platforms?
• Does their overall look and feel seem planned and professional?

Your Score (1-5): Their Score (1-5):

2

The 5-Second Test: Clarity of Message

Can a potential customer understand exactly what a business does and who it’s for within five seconds of landing on its homepage? Clarity wins against confusion.

Audit Questions:

• Is their core service and unique value immediately obvious?
• Is their messaging focused on customer problems and solutions?
• Is the language simple and direct?

Your Score (1-5): Their Score (1-5):

3

The Trust Factor: Online Reputation & Social Proof

Your reputation is built on Google reviews, testimonials, and customer photos. Brands that actively manage and showcase their reputation build a powerful moat of trust.

Audit Questions:

• What’s their average star rating on Google?
• How do they respond to reviews (both positive and negative)?
• Does their website feature testimonials or case studies?

Your Score (1-5): Their Score (1-5):

4

The Digital Storefront: Website Experience

Your website is your primary sales tool. A modern, fast, and mobile-friendly website is non-negotiable. An outdated site is like a rundown storefront.

Audit Questions:

• Is the website easy to navigate on a phone?
• Does it load quickly?
• Can you find contact info or a call-to-action in three seconds?

Your Score (1-5): Their Score (1-5):

5

The Aloha Spirit: Community Presence

A brand that feels like a genuine part of the local community has a massive advantage. This is about participating, not just existing.

Audit Questions:

• Does their social media show involvement in local events?
• Do they engage with comments from the community?
• Does their brand feel authentic to Hawaii?

Your Score (1-5): Their Score (1-5):

Total Score

Your Total

0

vs

Their Total

0

---

So, How Did You Score?

Tally up the points. Your Total: __ vs. Their Total: __

If you scored higher than your competitor: Congratulations. Your brand has a solid foundation. The key now is to maintain that lead by identifying your weakest category and focusing your efforts there.

If you scored the same or lower than your competitor: Don’t worry—this is an opportunity. You’ve just completed a competitive analysis that reveals exactly where your brand is falling behind. You now have a clear roadmap for improvement. Losing on points like visual consistency, message clarity, or website experience isn’t a permanent failure; it’s a sign that your brand’s strategy needs attention.

A strong brand doesn’t happen by accident. It’s the result of a deliberate, thoughtful process.

If you scored lower than your competitor, it's time to strengthen your brand. Our Creative Strategy & Branding service is the first step. At JB Brands, we turn these audit points into an action plan, building powerful, consistent, and memorable brands that win customers.

 

---